New York Pizzeria Menu

Welcome to New York Pizzeria, a hidden gem nestled in Trumansburg, NY. This unclaimed pizzeria brings authentic New York City pizza flavor to the Finger Lakes area, earning rave reviews from locals and visitors alike.

Guests have described their experience as pleasantly surprising, with the cheese pizza receiving particular acclaim for its rich flavor and genuine NYC style. The thin crust, perfectly balanced with generous toppings like pepperoni, feta, and olives, delights many.

New York Pizzeria is not only about great food; it offers great utility with takeout, delivery, outdoor seating, and accommodating options for groups and families. Whether you're looking for a casual lunch, dinner, or a late-night slice, this spot promises a satisfying experience.

If you crave authentic NYC-style pizza, New York Pizzeria should be your next stop!