Welcome to New York Pizzeria
At New York Pizzeria, located in Trumansburg, NY, we bring authentic New York City-style pizza to the Finger Lakes region. Our story is one of culinary passion, where every pie is crafted with high-quality ingredients, generous toppings, and a commitment to excellence. Customers rave about our crispy, flavorful crust and the rich, savory sauce that pairs beautifully with melted cheese. While we embrace the hustle and bustle of busy nights, our friendly staff ensures a warm, welcoming atmosphere. Whether you’re dining in or enjoying takeout, we aim to create memorable experiences with every slice, making us the go-to pizzeria for both locals and visitors alike.
New York Pizzeria: Reviews & Ratings
Revisited after a month and the kids agree, the cheese pizza is the closest thing you'll find to a real NY style pizza anywhere around here.
Really good pizza. Pleasantly surprised. We r from nyc and eat pizza all the time. Wasn't expecting this taste and quality. So glad we decided to get a large pie to go.
Finding a New York City Style pizza only shop in the Finger Lakes area was unexpected. I found this on par with most of the decent NY Pizza shops you find all over Manhattan. That is by no means a slight as I can rarely find those kinds of quality slices outside of NYC. I had a slice of black olive, feta, tomato, and my family had a pepperoni whole pie. The family liked it and thought the cheese was good, but it was very greasy, like most pizza shop pepperoni pizzas. The crust was thin but thick enough to handle the toppings and cracked when folded. No one ate their outer crust, so to me, that means it didn't have a good stand-alone flavor and was too chewy. NYC water really makes a difference. That being said, it's a good pizza if you're in NYC. Outside of NYC, it's a great quality pizzeria.
Food is always fantastic, best pizza and service is amazing, very friendly. Very good crust and just the right amount of sauce and cheese. Toppings are generous.
Pizza is stellar. Honestly as good as you would find anywhere. The only reason I didn't give it five stars was the delay. Was told 40 min and when we went back it had not yet been made. It's a busy town during summer so they were slammed. But because it's summer we weren't super thrilled about waiting another 40 minutes when our rental house was 20 minutes away. Staff was friendly and apologetic. Maybe a good practice to take a cell phone number on busy nights and just shoot a text.
Pizza is tasty & I love the crust. Do wish they carried wings tho! But definitely recommend the pizza!
Handcrafted pizza worth the wait. The negative reviews do not accurately or honestly describe the pizza. If you call, know what you want as they are busy and cannot spend time waiting for you to decide.
Delicious thin crust pizza, always perfectly crispy. The best. They have slices now but if you want a whole pie *you must plan properly* They're closed on Sundays and Mondays and their hours are shortened currently. Sometimes they have a long wait! Friday was 1.5 hours. Know that going in, and it IS worth it- promise.
Classic pizzaria. Slices are huge and the toppings look purposely placed to have one in every other mouthful, which is more than most places can say. The workers are enthusiastic and even ran to open the door for me. One of my pieces had a perfect crust and the other was a little too crunchy for my liking. The only thing that could make this place better is if the pizzas were labeled because not all of them are completely obvious with toppings.
Location
-
2 W Main Trumansburg, NY 14886 Hotline: (607) 387-3700
If you find yourself in the cozy town of Trumansburg, NY, one culinary gem you cannot overlook is New York Pizzeria. Nestled at 2 W Main, this unclaimed pizzeria brings a slice of the Big Apple to the Finger Lakes, creating a delightful dining experience for pizza enthusiasts and casual diners alike.
What sets New York Pizzeria apart? The praise from locals and visitors alike speaks volumes. Gary B. declared their cheese pizza to be the closest to authentic New York style found in the area, while Jan P., a New York City native, was pleasantly surprised by the quality and taste of their large to-go pie. The glowing reviews emphasize the pizzeria’s ability to replicate the beloved flavors of NYC, a feat not easily accomplished outside the city limits.
- Ambiance: The pizzeria offers a casual, quiet environment ideal for families and groups, making it a perfect spot for lunch or dinner. Outdoor seating is available for those who wish to enjoy their meal al fresco, alongside options for takeout and delivery.
- Menu Highlights: Guests rave about the variety, including the classic cheese, pepperoni, and creative toppings like black olives and feta. Many reviews highlight the well-balanced crust—thin yet sturdy enough to handle generous portions of toppings.
- Service: The staff is known for their friendly service and attentiveness. Despite occasional delays during busy summer nights, the team’s apologetic nature and commitment to customer satisfaction keep diners coming back.
The pizzeria is also well-equipped to cater to different needs; it accepts credit cards and Apple Pay, and even offers Wi-Fi, making it accessible for everyone. Whether you choose to dine in or grab a quick bite, New York Pizzeria embodies the essence of New York-style pizza with a local twist.
Do not miss the opportunity to indulge in a slice at New York Pizzeria. Whether you’re a native New Yorker or a local seeking a delicious meal, you’re in for a treat. It’s more than just pizza; it’s an experience that transports you to the bustling streets of Manhattan without leaving Trumansburg.
